Carpenter 158 vs 9310.

There are different grades of 9310. Vac Arc being the highest. More and more bolts are being made from it because of availability. 158 is controlled by Carpenter and you have minimum weight orders to meet or they will not sell to you. Some say 9310 has a slight advantage over 158, but looking at the chemical makeup, they are very similar.

Carpenter 158 vs 9310. Things To Know About Carpenter 158 vs 9310.

9310 is a standard. Carpenter 158 is proprietary alloy, and no real difference from 9310 in effective use of weaponry in a bolt. The difference between C-158 and 9310, I just don't see it. There is no evidence, let alone testing differences to the practical extent that it …PSA Logoed Premium 5.56 Nickel Boron BCG with Carpenter 158 Bolt - 516446450 . Rating: 94%. Regular Price $199.99 Special Price $99.99. Add to Cart. Add to Wish ...Carpenter 158 was originally developed as a dies steel and when carburized is best suited for application requiring high core strength and subjected to heavy shock and wear. Carburized 9310 is a very good steel when high core strength, toughness, fatigue, and wear properties are required.HRC of 46 yields a 15% increase in hardness at the same toughness comparing to Carpenter 158 & 9310; Mil-Spec Extractor and Ejector Springs, Gas Rings; While the two bolts have identical construction, the two coatings vary slightly. Here’s the information on both the DLC and NiB-X coatings. Technical Data on DLC Coating. …For instance; PSA, Aero Precision - both DPMS pattern- offer receivers, barrels, BCG's on their websites. What if I want to get a 3rd party BCG because of different specs - carpenter 158 vs 9310 bolt. Then - I assume the AR10 BCG will not run in …

Can somebody tell me what the difference is between c-158 and 9310 and why 9310 isn't mil-spec? I've seen 9310 used in some bolts and wonder if it's actually inferior. Is there technical data to show that c-158 is superior?The most common steel used in the bolt is Carpenter 158 steel. Some manufactures are using 9310 steel. Which is better? It depends who you ask, but most will agree that the difference in steel is small, and both varieties of steel work just fine. Many manufacturers also “shot peen” their bolts.

A lot of manufacturers offer a completely 9310 steel bolt carrier group. Though, this is a relatively new phenomenon and some people prefer the tried-and-true 8620 and Carpenter 158 combination. From my perspective, however, 9310 is an excellent option and is objectively stronger than 8620 and Carpenter 158 steel. Toolcraft Logo'd Carpenter 158 Nitride Full-Auto Bolt Carrier Group . Rating: 91%. Regular Price $129.99 Special Price $99.99. Add to Cart. Add to Wish List Add ...

I've seen 9310 used in some bolts and wonder if it's actually inferior. Is there technical data to show that c-158 is superior? Carpenter 158 Vs. 9310 - Page 10Conclusion. In conclusion, 9310 and 158 steel have unique properties and characteristics that make them ideal for certain applications. 9310 steel is tougher and more impact-resistant, while 158 steel is more corrosion-resistant. When choosing between the two, it’s important to consider your project’s specific requirements and needs.$ 185.00 $ 158.73 Add to cart. Sale! FREE SHIPPING ITEM! Faxon 308 WIN 16″ Big Gunner Barrel $ 239.00 $ 201.30 Add to cart. Sale! FREE SHIPPING ITEM!The Carpenter 158 has to be purchased in 20,000 Lb lots and is roughly $5/Lb. So I was wondering if there was another type of material out there that had the same chemical properties as the Carpenter 158, but could be purchased in smaller quantities (i.e. 1000 Lbs?)

The Relia-Bolt™ is machined from S7 tool steel and tempered with SRC’s proprietary heat-treating process, significantly increasing strength when compared to MilSpec Carpenter 158. S7 provides a 75% increase in tensile strength, and nearly 60% improvement in yield strength.-See it at Sharps here. Low Plasticity Roller Ball Burnishing:

HRC of 46 yields a 15% increase in hardness at the same toughness comparing to Carpenter 158 & 9310; Mil-Spec Extractor and Ejector Springs, Gas Rings; While the two bolts have identical construction, the two coatings vary slightly. Here’s the information on both the DLC and NiB-X coatings. Technical Data on DLC Coating. …

Apr 9, 2021 · If fact, 9310 response to thin section quenching is better that Carpenter 158. And, taking the leap between this statement:". . . by comparison to Carpenter 158, AISI 9310 has several elements present in its composition that are detrimental to fatigue while not being evident in the physical properties . . ." and this statement: Sep 22, 2021 ... HRC of 46 yields a 15% increase in hardness at the same toughness comparing to Carpenter 158 & 9310 ... or Carpenter 465 would be good materials ...9310 Steel. This is an excellent steel alloy with high core hardness and fatigue strength. It’s also replacing traditional 8620 and Carpenter 158 steel in many cases. 9310 steel has higher tensile and yield strength than 8620 steel, making it an excellent choice for bolt carrier construction.Made in USA. Bolt is made of Mil-spec Carpenter 158 steel, Shot peened, High pressure tested and Mag Particle Inspected. Gas key is machined out of bar stock, chrome lined phosphate coated, and secured with grade 8 fasteners and staked per mil-spec. Bolt carrier is phosphated outside and chrome lined inside. Laser engraved with the PSA logo.This Toolcraft Bolt is made of Mil-spec Carpenter 158 steel, shot peened, and mag particle inspected. Gas key is chrome lined, phosphate coated, and secured with grade 8 fasteners and staked per mil-spec. Full-auto bolt carrier is phosphate coated and chrome lined. Made in …

On the hardenability of steel, 4140 heat treatment has good strength and good comprehensive mechanical properties, good manufacturability, high yield. The highest temperature is 427 degrees Celsius. 4140 strength, high hardenability, and good toughness, quenching deformation of small, high temperature creep rupture strength, and high.Carpenter No. 158 Bolt Steel. This is Mil-Spec steel for bolt fabrication and offered case hardened steel to prevent cracking and surface wear. Tensile Strength: 1103 MPa; Yield Strength: 931 MPa; 9310 Steel. Similar to Carpenter No. 158 and is used for both carrier and bolt manufacturing, it is more widely available and is more affordable.Where are you seeing bolts made from 8620, or carriers and keys made from C158 or 9310? The BCM website states the bolt is made from C158. PSA states this as well. The Nickel Boron BCG I was interested in, made by Ground Zero Precision, states the carrier is 8620 steel, bolt is C158, and the cam pin is 4340 steel.The truth is, the standard Mil-spec C-158 (Carpenter 158) bolt has a number of factors limiting its performance, not the least of which is that the life expectancy of such bolts is only about 6,000 rounds. In fact, standard bolts will start to show stress cracks on the locking lugs adjacent to the extractor cut after only 3,000 rounds.For each property being compared, the top bar is SAE-AISI 4140 steel and the bottom bar is SAE-AISI 9310 steel. SAE-AISI 4140 (SCM440, G41400) Cr-Mo Steel SAE-AISI 9310 (1.6657, G93106) Ni-Cr-Mo Steel. Metric Units US Customary Units. Mechanical Properties. Brinell Hardness: 200 to 310: · Carpenter 158 is a case(surface) hardened steel where 8620/9310 is through hardened. Case hardening allows C-158 to be very hard on the outside to prevent wear …The Aero PRO BCG is a fairly new addition to Aeros lineup. This is a step above their standard option, but it is well worth the extra cost as the BCG is one of the most critical components of your rifle. The PRO BCG features an 8620 carrier, a 9310 bolt, and a 4140 Extractor, Cam Pin, and Gas Key. C158 is our preferred bolt material, but 9310 ...

The 9310 steel is another common material for bolts and carriers, but it’s cheaper and not as strong as the Carpenter 158. The tensile strength of 9310 steel comes in at 910 MPa, while its yield strength is 570 MPa. Finally, the 8620 steel is the cheapest option, and you can usually find it on the carrier, not the bolt. · 158 Mil Spec which means 158 material is on the TDP but as soon as the next TDP holder submits this material change to 9310 the US Government will accept it, …

Bolt is made of 158 carpenter instead of the 9310 i notice most others are. Is the 158 going to hold up fine its a hunting rig for a buddy that probly wont see a lot of rounds. Im sure they wouldnt be selling it if it wasnt up to par, thanks again guys. grayfox. 03-31-2018, 01:01 PM.Now the bolts, they are made with AISI 9310 Steel, 9310 is better suited for an application such as a M16 bolt. 9310 is a steel typically used for gears, cams and things of that nature while Carpenter 158 or P6 tool steel is a plastic injection mold steel. 9310 is easier to machine and is more dimensionally stable in the heat treat process, this equates to better made parts.*The extractors are ...Jul 11, 2020 ... 9310 is a far more widely used material in the metal industry than is C-158, & IF, & that's a REALLY big IF, it's heat treated correctly, it may ...Jan 1, 2020 · Carpenter 158 was what was spec'd in the 1950's when the rifle was made. One company in the world makes it, and it's Carpenter. Other metal alloys have come along since 1950-whatever that are definitely superior, I think 9310 is fine. So is polishing a radius on the cam pin hole in the bolt, which is where the cracks usually happen. Made in USA. Bolt is made of Mil-spec Carpenter 158 steel, Shot peened, High pressure tested and Mag Particle Inspected. Gas key is machined out of bar stock, chrome lined phosphate coated, and secured with grade 8 fasteners and staked per mil-spec. Bolt carrier is phosphated outside and chrome lined inside. Laser engraved with the PSA logo.The most popular steel alloys for BCGs are Carpenter 158 and 9310 steel. The BCG encounters plenty of stress and heat, which makes steel an ideal material. 9310 steel is strong and durable, making it common among manufacturers. Carpenter 158 is more commonly used by the military. Heat TreatmentI've seen 9310 used in some bolts and wonder if it's actually inferior. Is there technical data to show that c-158 is superior? Carpenter 158 Vs. 9310 - Page 15$ 185.00 $ 158.37 More Info. Sale! FREE SHIPPING ITEM! Ballistic Advantage 300 Blackout Performance Series 8.3 Hanson Barrel $ 210.00 $ 142.07 Add to cart. Sale! FREE SHIPPING ITEM! Ballistic Advantage 300 Blackout Performance Series 9 DRP Barrel $ 190.00 $ 134.81 More Info. Sale! FREE SHIPPING ITEM!HRC of 46 yields a 15% increase in hardness at the same toughness comparing to Carpenter 158 & 9310. Mil-Spec Extractor and Ejector Springs, Gas Rings. Technical Specification. Bolt: S7 Tool steel, …I’m aware that there are plenty of high quality 9310 steel bolts out there. I also know that it’s possible for high grade 9310 steel to be stronger than Carpenter 158 steel, if it’s heat treated properly. However, there are many suppliers of 9310 steel. And there’s some variation in the composition specifications for 9310 steel.

Carpenter 158 is a case (surface) hardened steel where 8620/9310 is through hardened. Case hardening allows C-158 to be very hard on the outside to prevent wear and crack formation while the inside is softer and more flexible to prevent crack propagation and absorb shock loads. 8620/9310 being through hardened can either be softer and better at ...

There are a couple of different popular bolt steels, notably 9310 and 158 Carpenter steel. Currently, MIL-SPEC steel based off Colt TDP is 158 Carpenter steel. The reason being is that it works, and it …

C158 minus proprietary source + molybdenum = 9310, a slightly stronger steel with lower quench rates to be come hard and less likely to become brittle than C158. C158 bolt breakages are the biggest failure point for the AR-15 bolt carrier group, and is the biggest reason why C158 is not widely used outside of the AR-15.Nov 16, 2017 · C-158 is simply Carpenters trade name for P-6 tool steel. P-6 and 9310 are very close in composition. The 9310 has some molybedenum while the P-6 has more chrome and nickel. 9310 is about half the cost of P-6. Which is better? Don't know, I barely made it through that class. IMO, the heat treat is probably more important than the alloy comp. In a rifle bolt there are only two things we need to be concerned with: the physical properties of the steel (hardness, strength, elasticity, etc), and shape. The physical properties of Carpenter 158 and 9310 are similar, and as long as the finished product passes gauging. the shape is correct.Apr 29, 2017 · Can somebody tell me what the difference is between c-158 and 9310 and why 9310 isn't mil-spec? I've seen 9310 used in some bolts and wonder if it's actually …Mar 8, 2020 · Well, 9310 is actually around 7% stronger than Carpenter 158 and is better than "mil-spec." faxonfirearms.com FWIW, Right To Bear has Toolcraft 9310 BCGs for $80. Carpenter 158 is 9310 with case hardening It's not, Carpenter 158 is a propitiatory steel alloy. It has similar (arguably superior) properties to 9310 but it is not 9310. All Toolcraft BCG bolts are shot-peened, MPI and batch HPT to ensure quality and reliability. Made from either mil-spec Carpenter 158 steel or high strength 9310 steel, bolt carrier groups from Toolcraft are guaranteed to perform like new for thousands and thousands of rounds. You cannot buy a better bolt carrier group than a Toolcraft.When comparing 8620 to Carpenter 158 you will notice that 158 has a much lower carbon content, and higher Chromium and Nickel content than 8620. 158 is truly an alloy metal, while 8620 is a low alloy metal. However in the world of steels that does not necessarily make it better but different.

I recently purchased a Toolcraft 5.56 NATO Black Nitride BCG....but choose 9310-Steel-Bolt instead of the Carpenter 158 steel bolt? Do I need to return it...The most common steel used in the bolt is Carpenter 158 steel. Some manufactures are using 9310 steel. Which is better? It depends who you ask, but most will agree that the difference in steel is small, and both varieties of steel work just fine. Many manufacturers also “shot peen” their bolts.A little more expensive, but easier to heat treat with little if any distortion. You can get 55 c scale with S-7 air quench. The other two have to be done in a carbon gas atmosphere . S-7 has a higher shock rating, but slightly less in the wear and abrasion than 9310 or 158.Instagram:https://instagram. p2188 audi a4ap psychology exam 2023 frqpsloginwalmart in crystal river florida 9310 Steel, Carpenter 158. Coating Type: Diamond-Like Carbon (DLC) Caliber: 223 Rem, 300 Blackout, 350 Legend, 5.56 NATO. Carrier Material: 8620 Steel. Manufacturer: Toolcraft. Features: Forward Assist Serrations. Compatibility: Standard AR15 components. Bolt Material: 9310 Steel, C158 Steel. Arm or Ally is a stocking dealer for all Aero ...When comparing 8620 to Carpenter 158 you will notice that 158 has a much lower carbon content, and higher Chromium and Nickel content than 8620. 158 is truly an alloy metal, while 8620 is a low alloy metal. However in the world of steels that does not necessarily make it better but different. afk arena ancient seal200 mcg is how many mg Firearm Discussion and Resources from AR-15, AK-47, Handguns and more! Buy, Sell, and Trade your Firearms and Gear. mcso inmate information There are different grades of 9310. Vac Arc being the highest. More and more bolts are being made from it because of availability. 158 is controlled by Carpenter and you have minimum weight orders to meet or they will not sell to you. Some say 9310 has a slight advantage over 158, but looking at the chemical makeup, they are very similar.Bren · #2 · Aug 21, 2019. I looked at a couple of PSA kits recently and the only difference was that one had a 9310 bolt and one had a C158. I doubt it makes any difference, but the C158 is the mil spec, so it has been tried and tested a lot more for a lot longer, so I went with that.